A Brief Discussion on the Application of Variable Frequency Technology in Energy-Saving Projects
2026-04-06 06:38:36··#1
The power supply we use in daily production and life is fixed-frequency (50Hz) alternating current. Variable frequency drive (VFD) technology uses technical means to change the power supply frequency of electrical equipment, thereby controlling the output power of the equipment. With the development of microelectronics, power electronics, computers, and automatic control theory, VFD technology has entered a new era. Its fully mature technology has also led to a new surge in its application. It changes the shaft output power through variable frequency speed control, thereby reducing input power and saving energy. It is one of the important energy-saving technologies for induction asynchronous motors. Since the birth of the world's first thyristor in 1956, nearly half a century has passed. With the rapid development of electronic technology, VFD controllers have become fully mature in terms of control modules, power output, and control software. While improving performance, their functions have also been greatly expanded. Many dedicated VFD devices come with simple PLC functions, and the reduction in product prices has opened up a vast market for VFD applications. There are many methods to achieve energy saving through speed regulation of asynchronous motors, such as: voltage regulation speed regulation, also known as slip speed regulation; pole-changing speed regulation and thyristor series speed regulation, etc., which are selected according to different load characteristics. Among various speed regulation energy saving methods, frequency conversion speed regulation is the most effective, mature, and promising energy-saving technology for asynchronous motors. I. Commonly used frequency converters are divided into low, medium, and high voltage frequency converters . 1. Low voltage frequency converters refer to 400V industrial control frequency converters. In electronic technology, converting AC to DC is called conversion, also known as rectification. Frequency converters that convert AC to DC are usually called rectifiers. Converting DC to AC current with adjustable frequency is called inversion. An inverter device that converts industrial frequency power supply (50Hz) AC to arbitrary frequency and voltage is called a frequency converter. From the perspective of its circuit structure, it is divided into AC-DC-AC and AC-AC frequency converters. AC-DC-AC frequency converters are divided into voltage type and current type according to the different control methods of AC motor power supply voltage. There are two different methods to change the output voltage or output current of a frequency converter: PAM (Pulse Amplitude Modulation) control and PWM (Pulse Width Modulation) control. PAM cannot operate at high frequencies due to the thyristor commutation time limitation. PWM output pulses have a constant amplitude. By controlling the frequency and width of the inverter's output voltage turn-off pulses, both the output frequency and voltage can be changed simultaneously. Transistors and turn-off thyristors, with their high-speed switching and self-turn-off characteristics, are used as the inverter's switching elements, making PWM control easier to implement. Therefore, most inverters use PWM control. 2. Medium and High Voltage Frequency Converters: Medium and high voltage frequency converters refer to frequency converters used in speed-regulating equipment operating at 600V to 10KV. Medium voltage includes 600V and 1000V. 3000V, 6000V, and 10KV are also considered medium and high voltage frequency converters. Because of its high input and output voltage levels, it requires a complete set of high-voltage switching equipment. It employs a high-voltage output method using series-superimposed power units, controlled by a computer, and comprises a high-voltage frequency conversion control system consisting of a high-voltage busbar, circuit breaker, phase-shifting transformer, power units, and controller. AC frequency converters are high-tech devices integrating power electronics, automatic control, microelectronics, and electrical engineering. Frequency conversion speed control technology is a cutting-edge technology in the modern IT industry, involving fiber optic communication, computers, and parallel data processing—a combination of multiple high technologies. It perfectly integrates with energy-intensive and widely used equipment in traditional industries such as electric drives, fans, and pumps that utilize asynchronous motors, achieving energy-saving retrofits. II. Variable Frequency Drive Control Objects Variable frequency drive applications can be divided into two main categories: one is for drive speed control, and the other is for various static power supplies (static power supplies will not be discussed here). The purpose of variable frequency drive speed control is to save energy by adjusting the speed of the motor. The controlled object is the motor that performs the electro-mechanical conversion on the power equipment. This is determined by the performance and characteristics of the induction asynchronous motor, and secondly by the load adaptability of the motor speed regulation to the load. From the mathematical formula for motor speed, we know that the actual speed of the motor mainly depends on the rotating magnetic field of the stator (n1=t*f/p). For a wound motor, the speed of its rotating magnetic field depends entirely on the power supply frequency, where t is the time constant, P is the number of pole pairs, and n1 is proportional to the power supply frequency f. From the motor's structure, we see that there is no electrical connection between the stator and rotor. Based on magnetic field induction and mechanical inertia, the rotor speed and the speed of the stator's rotating magnetic field are always out of sync, differing by a slip (generally 1%–1.8% of n1), called the slip rate S. Therefore, the motor speed is also proportional to the power supply frequency. n2=t*f(1-s)/p From the mechanical characteristic curve of the asynchronous motor during frequency conversion, we can easily see that the change in speed has little impact on the motor torque, and it can fully meet the power requirements of the transmission machinery. Variable frequency speed control reduces the output voltage while lowering the output frequency, and the torque is proportional to the output voltage. Torque will also decrease slightly. This purely electric speed control system artificially alters the mechanical characteristics of the motor to obtain different speeds. It connects directly to the driven machinery without requiring any adjustments to the original equipment, which is highly beneficial for energy-saving retrofits and maintaining the original mechanical performance. The characteristics of variable frequency drive speed control are: 1. No modification to existing equipment, including the motor itself; 2. Stepless speed regulation to meet the requirements of the transmission machinery; 3. Soft start and soft stop functions of the frequency converter avoid the adverse effects of starting current surges on the power grid, reducing power supply capacity while also reducing mechanical inertia and losses; 4. Unaffected by power supply frequency, allowing for open-loop and closed-loop manual/automatic control; 5. Good constant torque output and low-speed overload capacity at low speeds; 6. The motor's power factor increases with increasing speed and power. The overall performance is good. III. Energy Saving for Fans and Pumps — Variable Frequency Control Mechanical and Electrical Equipment Design Principles: The maximum power of the motor must meet the mechanical power and torque requirements under load. For different loads, the maximum value does not occur constantly, and load changes are non-linear, while the motor's output power remains constant. This means that when not under maximum load, the motor outputs a considerable amount of excess power, resulting in wasted electrical energy. Fans and pumps are typical examples. In the past, speed control was rarely used for controlling the airflow and flow rate of fans and pumps; they were primarily driven by squirrel-cage induction motors for constant speed operation. When changes in airflow or flow rate were needed, dampers or throttle valves were typically used. While this control method is simple and easy to implement and meets flow requirements, it is very uneconomical from an energy-saving perspective. This is easily detected in production. These devices generally operate for extended periods, sometimes even continuously. Actual testing revealed that, except for very short periods of maximum flow rate, they operate under medium or low load conditions for nearly 90% of the time, resulting in at least 40% of the total electricity consumption being wasted. Using variable frequency speed control to regulate the flow rate of mechanical components like fans and pumps is of great significance for energy conservation and improved economic efficiency. IV. Energy-Saving Methods for Fans and Pumps From the perspective of flow control principles, the structure and working principle of fans and pumps are basically the same. 1. Specific testing of the furnace bottom fan cooling control system in a factory: The smelting furnace, based on different materials and requiring different furnace bottom cooling temperatures, was designed to meet the maximum cooling airflow with four 18.5KW four-pole impeller fans operating at full power. However, the probability of using the maximum cooling airflow is extremely low. Several materials are commonly used in smelting. Four fans operating in pairs would result in excessive airflow; two fans operating in pairs would not meet the cooling requirements; one pair operating in pairs plus one fan operating to the side would lead to uneven cooling and fail to meet process requirements. The original design of four fans operating in pairs could meet the cooling requirements by adjusting the baffles, but this would waste electrical energy for the motors. With the fan fully open, the operating current is 24A, and with it fully closed, it's 22A. The input power varies from 17.0KW to 18.5KW, resulting in a power saving rate of less than 8%. To address this specific requirement, a solution was developed: open-loop variable frequency speed control was implemented on two of the split motors, working in conjunction with two full-speed fans. This met the temperature control requirements of different materials while saving energy. After implementing this solution, the energy-saving effect was very significant. For one material requiring fixed-frequency cooling, which only needs to be changed every few months, a frequency set between 25-35 Hz fully met the cooling requirements. Under mains frequency operation, a single 18.5KW fan (output via a frequency converter) consumes 11.9 kWh/hour, resulting in a daily power consumption of 285.6 kWh/24 hours. During normal operation, the frequencies were set to 25Hz, 30Hz, 35Hz, 40Hz, and 45Hz according to the temperature requirements of different materials. The operating parameters are as follows: It should be noted that when the inverter's output frequency decreases, the output voltage also decreases accordingly, resulting in a significant reduction in input power. Correspondingly, when the frequency decreases, the voltage drop will not cause a temperature rise in the motor. However, if the frequency remains constant and the voltage drops to the lower limit of the floating voltage, the motor will experience a temperature rise. 2. Water pump energy saving: The principle is very similar to that of a fan. Taking a 750TRT central air conditioning chiller unit in a hotel with a 90KW chilled water pump and a 55KW cooling water pump as an example: The chiller unit operates based on temperature changes and is a non-linear load, while the water pump motor is essentially a linear constant power output. A 55KW cooling water pump changes its flow rate by adjusting the valve. Although this meets the requirements of the chiller unit, it has little energy-saving significance for the motor. The current changes between 107A and 97A when the valve is fully open and fully closed, resulting in an average energy saving of less than 7%. By adopting temperature control as the primary method and pressure control as a secondary method for closed-loop variable frequency control of the water pump motor, the average energy saving rate of the water pump motor is over 30%. The 90KW chilled water pump motor, which relies on regulating valve current between 163-148A, had an average energy saving of less than 6%. After the closed-loop control variable frequency speed regulation modification, the average energy saving rate is also over 30%. Why is there such a large energy saving potential? Because the maximum capacity of the central air conditioning system is calculated based on three extreme indicators: maximum population flow, highest temperature, and worst space heat dissipation (i.e., maximum population flow, highest temperature, and worst space heat dissipation). The probability of this situation occurring under normal circumstances is extremely low, less than 10% empirically. The air conditioning system operates mostly under medium to low load conditions. The load curve of the air conditioning unit is non-linear, while the water pump load of the water system is linear and constant power, based on meeting the maximum load of the air conditioning unit. Therefore, when the air conditioning unit is not at its maximum load, the water pump inevitably wastes energy. Variable frequency speed regulation control makes the load curve of the water pump motor match or closely approximate the load curve of the air conditioning unit. 3. High-voltage variable frequency drive (VFD) speed control equipment typically uses large-capacity motors above 3KV, generally ranging from several hundred to several thousand KW, with a load rate greater than 0.5. Its energy-saving efficiency is slightly lower than low-voltage VFD control, around 18-25%. Larger motor capacities result in higher power consumption. Although the energy-saving rate is lower, the sheer volume of electricity consumed makes it considerable. High-voltage VFD equipment is technically complex, large in size, and expensive, requiring specialized technicians for operation. However, the overall benefits are still substantial. V. Analysis of the explicit and implicit benefits and advantages/disadvantages of VFD control technology : Explicit benefits refer to energy-saving benefits. The energy-saving rate of VFD speed control varies depending on the load characteristics and load rate. For low-voltage VFD control equipment, with a load rate of around 0.5, the energy-saving rate is generally around 20-47%. Examples include fixed-displacement pumps in injection molding machines, motors in sewage filling tanks, oxygen supply fans, and air conditioning water pumps, all with an average energy-saving rate of around 25-60%. Low-voltage equipment frequency conversion speed regulation retrofitting requires less investment and yields quick results, with a payback period of approximately one year. The implicit benefits are mainly reflected in: 1. It achieves soft start and soft stop of the motor, eliminating the impact of motor starting current on the power grid and reducing line losses; 2. It eliminates the mechanical impact of inertia caused by motor start-stop, greatly reducing mechanical wear, minimizing equipment maintenance, and extending equipment lifespan; 3. Soft start and soft stop of air conditioning water pumps overcomes the water hammer phenomenon that previously occurred during shutdown. However, besides these advantages, some problems also exist. Nothing is absolute; everything must be viewed and analyzed dialectically. The output waveform of low-voltage frequency converters is pulse-shaped, which can generate some interference. In actual operation, the interference from a single unit is not severe. Taking a 30KW capacity as an example, the interference radiation is generally within 10 meters. Adding a notch filter circuit, magnetic ring, or notch coil to the circuit design can minimize interference. Generally, it should be kept away from interference-sensitive equipment such as computers. When multiple units are installed together, the installation locations should be spaced as far apart as possible, and a dedicated notch filter circuit with shielding and grounding should be installed to minimize interference. High-voltage frequency converters have very low interference and advanced control technology, producing an output voltage waveform that approximates a sine wave. However, the equipment is relatively large, and installation and commissioning are complex. VI. Current Market Application of Frequency Converter Technology Market research shows that before 2000, the usage rate of frequency converters was less than 10%, but by the first half of 2007, it had increased by more than 35%. Many manufacturers have equipped their fan and pump motor control systems with frequency converter starting systems, indicating that this energy-saving technology is becoming increasingly recognized. With the continuous increase in market share, the cost has decreased significantly compared to previous years. Low-voltage frequency converters are divided into three main categories: domestic, joint venture, and original equipment manufacturer (OEM), and are essentially universal industrial control products. Joint venture products are relatively inexpensive and of good quality, offering a reasonable cost-performance ratio. In terms of usage, failures are rare as long as the system is not overloaded. From a design and usage perspective, the quality of energy-saving retrofit designs varies greatly; to ensure the success of energy-saving retrofit projects, professional technicians are required to oversee the process. Whether electrical equipment can save electricity cannot be generalized indiscriminately. Not all electrical equipment has potential for energy savings; specific situations must be analyzed individually. Be wary of claims that the energy-saving rate of a particular piece of equipment can be universally applied to all electrical equipment. Energy-saving rate is a crucial indicator in energy-saving projects, but it is by no means the only one. The power factor, temperature rise, and efficiency of motors before and after the modification are all significant operational data points. Different energy-saving equipment has different energy-saving rates, lifespans, and performance characteristics, requiring scientific analysis and application. Although my country's industrial technology has made significant progress, it is still in the mid-stage of industrialization, with uneven technological development. In many enterprises, the most prominent characteristics remain high energy consumption, low production efficiency, and inconsistent product quality; energy efficiency ratios are not high, and outdated equipment still constitutes a large proportion of national production. The application of variable frequency speed control aims to upgrade these devices to achieve energy savings. With strong support from national, provincial, and municipal governments, and a mature technological foundation, the energy-saving renovation market has enormous potential. Saving energy, protecting the environment, benefiting future generations, and contributing to the country and its people.