Application and Selection of Radar Level Gauges in Cement Plants
2026-04-06 07:20:38··#1
I. Overview Level is one of the main measurement parameters in the cement industry production process. Unlike other industries, the cement industry primarily focuses on the level measurement of solid materials, with liquid level measurement being less common. Solid materials are diverse, including lumps, granules, and powders, each with varying dielectric constants, bulk densities, temperatures, and moisture contents. Contact measurement methods, such as capacitance, weighted, tuning fork, and rotary paddle methods, were the main means of level measurement in the past. However, because the instrument and material are in contact during measurement, various problems often arise during use, such as material buildup in capacitance meters, broken or embedded weighted hammers, and material blockage in tuning forks. Furthermore, daily maintenance is extensive. In the 1990s, the cement industry began to adopt non-contact level measurement. Early mature non-contact measurement technologies included ultrasonic technology and nuclear radiation technology (gamma rays). However, the application of nuclear radiation technology is limited due to the presence of a radioactive source. Ultrasonic technology has developed rapidly in recent years and is currently the most widely used non-contact measurement method, especially in liquid level measurement. Ultrasonic level measurement is widely used in cement plants, including raw material blending silos, raw coal silos, and clinker silos. However, ultrasonic waves must be propagated through a medium. For example, air is usually used as the propagation medium for level measurement in cement plant storage silos. Changes in air temperature, humidity, and composition can affect the propagation speed of ultrasonic waves, and dust in the air can also attenuate the ultrasonic wave signal. Currently, ultrasonic level measurement is only used to measure block or granular materials. For measuring the level of powder silos, the surface of the powder silo is very loose during material feeding, which strongly attenuates the ultrasonic signal. Therefore, there are no successful precedents for measuring the level of powder silos to date. In the late 1990s, high-performance, low-cost microwave level gauges, also known as radar level gauges, emerged in the process monitoring field. Microwaves are electromagnetic waves with a frequency range of 300MHz to 300GHz. The propagation speed of microwaves is 3 x 10⁸ m/s. For example, at a frequency of 5.8GHz, the wavelength in the atmosphere is approximately 52mm. Microwaves have strong penetrating power, and their propagation speed is unaffected by dust, steam, or the composition of the medium, with minimal propagation attenuation. For the solid materials being measured, besides requiring a dielectric constant ε > 1.8, the temperature, pressure, and density of the material have almost no impact on accurate measurement. Existing radar level gauges have antenna designs and shapes that ensure the energy of the received echoes. Furthermore, on-site debugging is very simple; using dedicated software, the correct echo can be quickly located and immediately converted into a level value. Due to their superior performance compared to ultrasonic level gauges, radar level gauges have rapidly and extensively entered the process monitoring instrument market in recent years and are widely used in various industries. In the cement industry, radar level gauges almost dominate the field of level measurement. According to statistics, in recent years, nearly 90% of the various warehouses and silos of newly designed large cement plants and grinding stations have adopted various types of radar level gauges. Tianwei's PLUS54 fieldbus type PA radar level gauge has also been successfully used in eight cement warehouses of three cement production lines of Yunnan Hongta Dianxi Cement Company, forming a new FCS system with other instruments. II. Radar Level Measurement Principle and Main Technical Factors Radar level gauges utilize the principle of echo ranging. The transmitting antenna emits microwaves to the target being measured, and the microwaves of the target being measured are received by the receiving antenna. The signal processor compares the transmitted signal with the received signal, calculates the distance to be measured, and can calculate the corresponding level value. The round-trip propagation time t of the microwave pulse is determined by the following formula: t = (1) Where a—distance from the antenna to the target being measured c—speed of microwave propagation (speed of light) Since microwaves have attenuation and interference reflections in the propagation path, the key to measurement is to be able to receive the reflected echo and identify the effective echo. The received echo energy Pk can be expressed by a simplified radar equation as follows: Pk=Pτx C x GiGtGr/r4 (2) Where: Pτ—antenna radiated power C —- empirical coefficient, determined by experience Gi —- reflection gain determined by the dielectric properties and area of the target surface Gt, Gr—antenna transmission and reception efficiency r—distance between the antenna and the target From equation (2), we know that the received echo energy is related to the antenna transmission and reception efficiency and the antenna radiated power. Therefore, the antenna design and shape of the radar level gauge are very important. In addition to horn antennas (horn mouth) and rod antennas, existing antennas also include planar antennas and parabolic antennas. For materials with small dielectric constants, cables are used as antennas or waveguides are installed. The cables and waveguides extend all the way to the bottom of the warehouse or silo to transmit and receive electromagnetic waves, thereby enhancing the signal of the echo. From equation (2), we also know that the amount of received echo energy is related to the dielectric properties of the material surface. A high dielectric constant ε results in a high reflectivity and a high echo intensity. A low dielectric constant ε means that the material will absorb some of the microwave energy, resulting in a lower echo intensity. Generally, the dielectric constant ε of the material being measured is required to be: ε>1.8 for liquids, ε>2.5 for solids, ε>2.5 for cement solids, and ε=3 for cement. In cement plants, various solid materials are stored in warehouses or silos, and there is an angle of repose for the materials. The echo reflection will also have diffuse reflection like ultrasound, generating interference echoes and false echoes. Interference echoes and false echoes can be eliminated by software, but the effective echo intensity will be greatly reduced. Therefore, attenuation should be considered when designing and selecting the model, and a certain margin should be left when selecting the range. Three. Selection of Radar Level Gauges 1. Pulse and Frequency Modulated Continuous Wave Radar Radar level gauges used for measuring material level are generally divided into two categories: pulse radar and frequency modulated continuous wave radar (FMCW). In process monitoring applications, pulse radar is primarily chosen due to its lower frequency (6.3GHz), the fact that its antenna structure design fully considers the effects of condensation and material accumulation, and its ability to utilize echo signal processing from ultrasonic level gauges. It can also identify effective echoes even in complex operating conditions such as those with agitators, and its relatively lower price makes it a popular choice in the cement industry. VEGAPULS pulse radar (represented by VEGA) and Micropilot M FMR radar (represented by E+H) are also widely used. Frequency-modulated continuous wave (FM-CW) radar, due to its high transmission power, large range, significantly reduced price, and high reliability, has recently seen increased adoption in the cement industry, with LR-type FM-CW radar (represented by SIEMENS) becoming more common. 2. Selection of Granular Materials: Most raw materials in cement plants are granular, with a few being lumpy, such as limestone, raw coal, and shale. The semi-finished clinker is also granular, stored in silos or warehouses, and thus has an angle of repose, but also a reflective interface. Based on the material's angle of repose and surface conditions formed during feeding and unloading, after determining the effective range, it is recommended to use a non-contact radar level gauge, i.e., a level gauge with a rod-shaped or horn-shaped antenna. Using a contact-type radar level gauge would generate a large downward pull on the cable, potentially causing an accident. According to feedback from cement plants, level gauges with horn-shaped antennas have stronger echoes and higher accuracy (±0.2~±1% FS), with commonly used models being PULS54 or SITRANS LR400. 3. Selection of Level Gauges for Powdered Materials: Cement plants and grinding stations typically have 4-8 cement silos, as well as raw material homogenization silos and fly ash silos. All these materials are powdery, making level measurement extremely difficult. The surface of powder materials in the silo is very loose, making microwave reflection quite difficult. Therefore, it is recommended to use a contact radar level gauge. Alternatively, a non-contact radar level gauge with a large flange and horn antenna can be selected. Typical products include the VEGA-FLEX52K and E+H's FMP40 cable-type radar level gauge. This type of gauge combines the cable as both an antenna and a waveguide. Microwave pulses are emitted from the probe and propagate along the cable. When the pulse encounters the material surface, it is reflected back. Its range can reach 35m, and the dielectric constant ε of the measured material is as low as 1.6. Furthermore, the cable's wear resistance and maximum tensile strength can meet the detection requirements of various powder silos in cement plants. Currently, many cement plants, such as Hailuo Digang, Zhejiang Sanshi, Shaanxi Yaoxian, and Gansu Qilianshan cement plants, have used cable-type radar level gauges to measure the material levels in cement and fly ash silos with good results. Due to the complex operating conditions of the homogenization silo, it is recommended to use VEGA-PULS68 or Siemens products, specifically the SITRANS LR400, 24GHz, with a maximum range of 45m and a four-wire system. 4. Two-wire system: Most currently used radar level gauges are integrated products, powered by a two-wire system. They can be directly connected to control system modules, outputting 4-20mA analog signals, saving significant cabling costs. They also provide HART digital signals and digital communication functions for various fieldbus protocols, making connection to computer monitoring systems very convenient. Debugging can be done on-site or in the control room using a PC. If an FCS system is configured, debugging can also be done at the operator station. IV. Conclusion: Level measurement in cement plants is an important component of the cement production line automation system. The application of radar level gauges has alleviated concerns about level measurement in cement plants. Existing radar level gauges meet the requirements of cement plant detection and control in terms of variety, accuracy, standard materials, pressure resistance, high temperature resistance, and explosion protection.